Are German Shepherds More Aggressive Than Pit Bulls

Are Pit Bulls More Dangerous Than Other Dog Breeds

60-year-old Archie Hillard was hospitalized as a result of a pit bull attack in Norwalk, Connecticut in August 2012. He sustained dog bite injury to his left leg and arm, and according to news reports, his ankle was chewed to the bone. Police state that it took four officers with tasers to subdue the dog.

The incident happened when the owner was walking the dog, and it broke free and attacked Hillard. Supposedly, the dog had a history of previously attacking people.

Are pit bulls more dangerous than other breeds of dog?

If the extent of this mans injuries is true, then it supports the belief that attacks by pit bull type dogs can lead to more serious injury when compared with attacks from other breeds of dog. This is noteworthy, because there are now reports in the medical literature, which support this contention.

Importantly note, however, that the above does not necessarily mean that pit bull type dogs are more likely to bite people when compared with other breeds of dog.

First, note that a pit bull is not a breed of dog. Rather, it is a descriptive term to indicate the physical appearance of a dog. A dogs physical appearance may not correspond to its genotype, and this is particularly true when it comes to mixed breed dogs.

Dog Bite Resources

History Of The Pitbull

As for the Pitbull, its important to realize that the term refers to a few different breeds.

What breeds fall under the Pitbull name is subject to some debate, but most agree that the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, and Staffordshire Bull Terrier all fit into this category.

While each Pitbull breed has their own history, they each share an unfortunate background of being forced to take part in blood sports.

They were bred to fight other dogs, or in some cases, larger animals such as bears. Spectators would bet on the outcome.

This cruel practice was outlawed across Britain in the mid-18th century, however, it wasnt until 1976 that dog fighting was outlawed across all states in America.

Despite their brutal past, Pitbulls find themselves leading fulfilling lives as companion dogs with the right loving owners.

Mixed Breed Dog Temperament

As we mentioned earlier, proper training and socialization with other dogs and humans from an early age can help to prevent a puppy with German Shepherd lineage from developing aggressive behavior later in life.

As with any hybrid puppy, Shepherd Pitt puppies may be more or less like one or both of their parent breeds. For this reason, it is imperative to meet both parents and ensure they are friendly and relaxed examples of their breeds.

Any German Shepherd or Pitbull mix will potentially display more aggression than other breeds.

You May Like: Is Purina Pro Plan Good For German Shepherds

Would A German Shepherd Kill A Pitbull

The pit bull is much more likely to attack your GSD than to attack you. In either case, the GSD is not likely to be able to defend itself against a pit bull. Theyre not bred for that type of scenario. GSDs can be trained to attack, and for that matter, can be trained to kill, and thats not insignificant.

Is The German Shepherd A Dangerous Dog

The American Animal Hospital Association conducted a study and concluded that German Shepherds were one of the most dangerous breeds based on bite severity and frequency of biting. This is not surprising given the fact that German Shepherds have one of the most powerful bites of all breeds.

You May Like: How Big Do Beagle Mixes Get

Why Are Pit Bulls Often Targeted With Breed

Its time to separate fact from feelings. According to a 2000 study, more than half of dog-related deaths between 1979-1998 were reportedly caused by pit bulls or Rottweilers. However, more than 25 different breeds of dogs were implicated in dog-caused fatalities as well.

Most dogs that actually cause deaths have certain physical characteristics. Theyre large, very muscular, have a low center of gravity, and extremely powerful jaw muscles. Many of these dogs were even bred to attack and protect other animals and people.

It sounds pretty bad when you look at it on the surface like that. So, lets dig in deeper.

First, its pretty hard to identify pit bulls in the first place. Dont believe me? Check out this site. Its sort of a generic term to begin with, and doesnt really apply to any one breed of dog except the American Pit Bull Terrier. In fact, one 2013 study showed that it was actually pretty common for media and official accounts of dog breed to vary in cases where people had been killed by dogs.

Second, there are millions of pit bulls in the U.S. right now. Most are loving family members. So, what causes a good pit bull to go bad? The same study pointed out a host of factors that led to people being killed by dogs.

Who Is Impacted By Breed

Regulated breeds typically comprise the pit bull class of dogs, including American Pit Bull Terriers, American Staffordshire Terriers, Staffordshire Bull Terriers and English Bull Terriers. In some areas, regulated breeds also include a variety of other dogs like American Bulldogs, Rottweilers, Mastiffs, Dalmatians, Chow Chows, German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers or any mix of these breedsand dogs who simply resemble these breeds.

Many states, including New York, Texas and Illinois, favor laws that identify, track and regulate dangerous dogs individuallyregardless of breedand prohibit BSL. However, more than 700 U.S. cities have enacted breed-specific laws.

Also Check: What To Do If A German Shepherd Attacks You

How Aggressive Is A Pitbull

Some of the Pit Bull breeds were originally used for dogfighting before they were adopted as pets. This is why a lot of people think that Pit Bulls might be genetically aggressive.

It is not true. Pit Bulls are extremely loyal towards their owner and his family members and will not hurt them.

They also love socializing and gel up well with strangers. However, this might not be the case with other animals.

Pit Bulls are not aggressive with humans but may not tolerate other pets. They have high energy levels and hardly ever get tired. Their constant need to exercise and play might look like a form of aggression, but that is not true.

Also, it is easy to train Pit Bulls due to their loyal, obedient and pleasing nature. Well-trained Pit Bulls do not show aggressive tendencies.

On the other hand, a Pit Bull who hasnt received proper training might be aggressive and dangerous. This goes for all the dog breeds.

Those that receive good training are calm and know how to react in situations. Those who lack proper dog training may grow up to be aggressive. It can be said that Pit Bulls, in general, are not aggressive.

Related:

Video Answer: Verify: Are Pit Bulls The Most Dangerous Breed Of Dog

When comparing the Doberman vs German Shepherd to determine which is stronger, it will be a close contest indeed! … The German Shepherd dog weighs 50 to 90 pounds and stands 22 to 26 inches tall in adulthood. Again, males of the breed tend to be taller and stronger than females.

GS is stronger than pitbull

Read Also: Black Long Hair German Shepherd

How Should You Train A German Shepherd Pitbull Mix

With patience!

There are several types of training required: obedience, discipline, agility and socialization.

Each is important to help this type of puppy learn to socialize and behave. This looks like a dangerous dog so it is important to train it to challenge perceptions and show people the best of this breed instead.

Video Answer: German Shepherd Vs Pitbull / In Hindi / Which Dog Is Best

German Shepherd Shedding and Grooming.

German shepherds also have a double layer, water repellent coat, although theirs is shorter and straight.

Like Goldens, GSDs will “blow coat” at least twice annually with the changing of the seasons.

Border Collies are highly energetic and loyal towards their family but they are less dominating. Like the German Shepherd they do display instincts to guard their family but often by keeping their distance and keeping an eye out. Both of these dog breeds are highly intelligent and thrive with training and direction.

Equally, due to their fur type and longer coat, German shepherds do have a higher potential for odor if not well-groomed and maintained. Unfortunately, just like any breed of dogs, German shepherds will smell somewhat Some dogs are smellier than others, not that we love them any less, but that’s just the way it is.

The American Animal Hospital Association conducted a study and concluded that German Shepherds were one of the most dangerous breeds based on bite severity and frequency of biting. This is not surprising given the fact that German Shepherds have one of the most powerful bites of all breeds.

Don’t Miss: How Often Should I Walk My German Shepherd

How The Test Is Conducted

According to the ATTS, the test “focuses on and measures different aspects of temperament such as stability, shyness, aggressiveness, and friendliness as well as the dogs instinct for protectiveness towards its handler and/or self-preservation in the face of a threat.”

The test simulates a walk through the neighborhood where the dog encounters neutral, friendly, and threatening situations. A series of strangers approach the handler, and surprising noises are emitted from secret locations. The test’s goal is to examine how the dog reacts to people, noises, and its surrounding environment.

The German Shepherd Is Old

If your German Shepherd is old and weak, then the dog probably wont be able to hold up against a young, strong, aggressive pitbull.

In addition, if a pitbull is particularly large, this would give the dog an even bigger advantage.

All of these factors must be taken into account when assessing the chances of either dog winning a fight.

Another factor to consider is the diet. If the pitbull is fed a poor diet and is weak and emaciated, the pitbull may not be able to beat a German Shepherd.

On the other hand, if the pitbull is fed a fatty diet and is weighed down by a lot of extra fat, the pitbull is also more likely to lose.

A strong dog is one that is fed a healthy diet that is rich in protein, iron, and nutrients but is still mostly muscle, with a low body fat percentage.

The same goes for your German Shepherd. If your dog receives a much better diet than the pitbull, your dog can beat the pitbull.

But if a weak and emaciated or a fat German Shepherd faces off a strong and well-fed pitbull, the pitbull will probably win.

Recommended Reading: Are German Shepherds Part Wolf

What Is Life Like For A Gspm

Lifestyle

Theyre easy to care for as they like to keep themselves active and have fun, with lots of tasks and play and at their best when doing something energetic and not alone.

Otherwise, with their high energy levels they may show their boredom through destroying or chewing things and barking.

Theyre not suited to small living spaces and need lots of outdoor space to run around, with or without company.

They can make a great family dog. However, if you are not able to match their energy levels or be there for them then theyre not the dog for you!

Remember just how active this dog is before choosing one.

A Quick guide to the Positives and Negatives

Positives

• Loving, protective and easy to look after
• Fiercely loyal to Master and family
• Very intelligent
• Easy to train and groom
• Very energetic and active
• Sociable, gentle and likes to play
• Good with children and other dogs, when trained

Negatives

• Looks like a dangerous dog
• Can be stubborn and challenge for dominance
• Can get unsettled if not occupied
• They Can destroy things and bark if left alone or bored
• Not suited to living in a small space, or inside
• Shouldnt be left alone with small children
• Can easily gain weight which is not good for their hips

Can A Dogo Argentino Beat A Pitbull

The Dogo Argentino and the American Pitbull Terrier are similar in looks, so much so that the Dogo Argentino is often mistaken for an APBT, and a white APBT is often mistaken for a Dogo Argentino.Breed Comparison Chart.Dogo ArgentinoPitbull TerrierLifespan9-15 years12-16 yearsPrice$2,000+$800+6 more rowsSep 18, 2020

Dont Miss: Why Do German Shepherds Whine So Much

Recommended Reading: German Shepherd Vs Rottweiler Who Would Win

German Shepherd Vs Pit Bull: Which Breed Is Simpler To Train

What many people dont realize is that Pit Bulls are pretty easy to train. When it comes to trainability, however, German Shepherds are unbeatable. These intelligent dogs were bred to learn numerous commands.

As such, they take a lot of pleasure in their training. Training also serves as mental stimulation from German Shepherds, helping them become calmer and happier dogs. There is no end to what you can teach this breed.

Pit Bulls arent too far behind. These dogs love to please their owners and using positive reinforcement will ensure that your dog thrives at their training.

Some Pit Bulls can have a dominant or Alpha dog mentality. With these pups, it is important to show that you are the leader of the group from the moment that you bring the puppy home. This will make training go a lot smoother.

With both breeds, starting socialization and training as early as possible is key. It will help your pup to avoid bad habits and ensure that the good ones sink in at an early stage.

Are German Shepherds Aggressive

The German Shepherd breed is known for their aggressive behaviors and tendencies. In fact, they are often touted for this behavior and it is utilized to make good, strong guard dogs. German Shepherds are considered good guard dogs but if they are not trained guard dogs, then you need to curb any aggressive tendencies.

Recommended Reading: Coyote Vs Pitbull Fight

Understanding Pit Bull Facts & Pit Bull Statistics

Did you know that pit bull isnt actually a breed? Most dogs labeled as pit bulls are mixed breed dogs.

We all think we know what a pit bull breed is, but do we? Recent studies show that the vast majority of pit bull-type dogs are mixed breeds containing less than 50% DNA of pit bull ancestry.

Dogs are labeled as pit bulls or pit bull-type dogs based on specific physical characteristics that include:

• A large, broad head

• American bulldogs
• Mastiffs

The American pit bull terrier is a breed recognized by the United Kennel Club but not by the American Kennel Club .

How I Determined Which Dog Breeds Are The Most Dangerous

The 10 breeds listed below had some of the lowest overall passing rates in the temperament test conducted by the American Temperament Test Society and are sorted in order from lowest to the highest percentage of individual dogs that passed. Breeds with the lowest passing percentages frequently showed signs of aggression, panic, or extreme shyness during the test.

While there are breeds with even lower passing percentages than those mentioned in this article, I’ve decided to limit this list to the 10 breeds that are most frequently ranked as highly aggressive . Each breed on the list is discussed in greater detail in the sections below, and overall passing rates are included for each.

Recommended Reading: Pitbull Vs Rott

Can German Shepherds Kill Pit Bulls

The pit bull is much more likely to attack your GSD than to attack you. In either case, the GSD is not likely to be able to defend itself against a pit bull. Theyre not bred for that type of scenario. GSDs can be trained to attack, and for that matter, can be trained to kill, and thats not insignificant.

Why Are Shelters Full Of Pit Bulls

Part of the reason those dogs stay in a shelter for so long is because many apartment complexes or landlords dont allow the breed. Thats because those dogs have a stigma associated with them since historically theyve been bred for fighting or other aggressive activities.

Read Also: How To Draw A German Shepherd Easy

Training And Exercising Your German Shepherd Pitbull Mix

Since Shepherd Pitts are especially prone to hip dysplasia, youll need to take extra precautions to ensure that your dog doesnt become obese. This is especially important if your dog has hypothyroidism in its genes.

Youll need to plan for daily walks, play time, and off-leash exercise.

Additionally, both Pitbulls and German Shepherds are working breeds that are high energy. Its therefore best to keep them where they can play and run in a yard.

They wont be happy living in a small apartment or spending long periods in a dog crate.

As mentioned earlier, your puppy will need to be thoroughly socialized from the day you bring him home.

You can find more information and guides on training here.

What Are The Alternatives To Breed

There is no convincing data to indicate that breed-specific legislation has succeeded anywhere to date.

The CDC has noted that many other factors beyond breed may affect a dogs tendency toward aggressionthings such as heredity, sex, early experience, reproductive status, socialization and training. Conversely, studies can be referenced that point to clear, positive effects of carefully crafted breed-neutral laws. A breed-neutral approach may include the following:

• Enhanced enforcement of dog license laws

• Increased availability to low-cost sterilization services

• Dangerous dog laws that are breed-neutral and focus on the behavior of the individual guardian and dog

• Graduated penalties and options for dogs deemed dangerous

• Laws that hold dog guardians financially accountable for failure to adhere to animal control laws

• Laws that hold dog guardians civilly and criminally liable for unjustified injuries or damage caused by their dogs

• Laws that prohibit chaining, tethering and unreasonable confinement, coupled with enhanced enforcement of animal cruelty and animal fighting laws

• Community-based approaches to resolving reckless guardian/dangerous dog questions that encompass all stakeholders, available dog bite data and recommended realistic and enforceable policies

Recommended Reading: Walking German Shepherd Puppy