Which Breed Is Better
So which breed is the better fit for families, based on their temperament?
We would say the German Shepherd is best for most families.
They are easier to control and noticeably less dangerous than some Pitbulls.
Additionally, they are free from much of the dangerous dog legislation that affects the Pitbull.
However, this doesnt mean the Pitbull is a lost cause, but they might be better suited to an experienced owner who is willing to put in the extra time to raise them.
Who Would Win In A Fight A Pitbull Or German Shepherd
It would be a close fight because German Shepherds have a bite force of 238 pounds of pressure measured bite force, and the American Pit Bull Terrier has a bit force of 235 pounds of pressure but most of the time a Shepherd and a pit would go strait for the throat so most likely the fist one to get a bite in would win.
Can A Rottweiler Beat A Pitbull
Rottweilers are one such breed of dogs that can beat a Pit Bull. A rottweiler is larger in size than a Pit Bull. He is more intelligent, agile, stronger, and powerful when compared to a Pit Bull. Due to a more aggressive nature and the ability to tear off the flesh easily, a rottweiler can defeat a Pit Bull.
Also Check: What Colors Do German Shepherds Come In
Which Is Most Dangerous Dog In World
International Dog Day 2020: 6 most dangerous dog breeds in the worldAmerican Pit Bull Terrier. 1/6. American Pit Bulls are one of the most dangerous dogs and have been banned by many countries in the world. Rottweiler. 2/6. German Shepherd. 3/6. American Bulldog. 4/6. Bullmastiff. 5/6. Siberian Husky.
German Shepherd Vs Pitbull How Do They Stack Up
June 5, 2019 By //;;by;Ryan Jones
Interested in the German Shepherd vs Pitbull debate? There are some key differences between these two impressive breeds!
GSDs have a long working history, and as a result they are often easier to train. But, due to an insalubrious previous career as fighting dogs, many regions still prohibit Pitbulls.
Plus, the GSDs long coat needs more upkeep than any of the Pitbull types.
But what other factors should you consider when choosing between these two breeds?
Recommended Reading: Do German Shepherds Like Other Dogs
Dogfighting Goes Back Centuries
Today, dogfighting is illegal in most developed countries and considered animal cruelty with huge penalties and even jail time for the owner.
Where it remains legal, the blood sport of dogfighting is divided into categories:
- Street fighting
In parts of the Russian Federation and Japan, dogfighting remains a legal sport.
Elsewhere, even if it’s officially unlawful to organize dogfighting events, the law turns a blind eye on it in Latin America, Pakistan, some Eastern European countries.
It’s even occasionally spotted in the U.S. and the U.K.
According to a story from NPR, dogfighting sport have originated when the ancient Romans would pit fighting dogs against each other in gladiator-style fights to the death.
These fights last up until one dog dies, exits the pit, or fails to scratch.
As history shows, the dog who loses the battle is then shot by its owner, tortured, or beaten severely.
Other than the entertainment aspect of dogfighting, there are large sums of cash at stake. Money is made by charging stud fees and admission.
Thus, a gambling format is reached. People can bet on a certain fighter dog to win some extra dough.
Fortunately, in today’s society, we find the idea of;two dogs being;forced to fight against each other for sheer entertainment repulsive and immoral.
In fact, dog fighting is considered a felony in all 50 states in the United States, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, and many other countries.
Choosing Between A German Shepherd Vs Pitbull
These two well-known dog breeds have massive reputations, but how do they compare against one another?
The German Shepherd is a very popular breed, but both of these breeds have had controversy surrounding them in the past.
In this article, we will be covering everything from temperament to health issues in these two breeds to find out once and for all which is the better breed as a family dog.
So lets see what we can find out!
Read Also: What To Know About German Shepherd Breed
German Shepherds Vs Pitbulls: Things Worth Considering
While there have been incidents of violence with these breeds, dog incidents are not exclusive to these two dogs. In fact, in most cases, these sorts of incidents can be attributed to an irresponsible owner.
Theres also the issue of people not taking the time to learn about specific breeds, and the training they require.
Both of these breeds respond well to early and consistent training, and typically have fewer issues once they are trained.
With German shepherds and Pitbulls, it is important to understand the breed you are investing in, and to plan accordingly.
These are both high energy dogs that require a lot of energy-burning exercises, as well as tons of;love and care.
Would Rottweiler Win A Fight With Two German Shepherds
Franky: Who would win in a fight a Rottweiler or 2 German Shepherds?The Rottweiler is fully grown and trained. Two German shepherds are fully grown but not trained.
Answers and Views:
Answer by Yash patelNo never,…. only one working line GSD is capable to destroy one fully grown Rottweiler … In my farmhouse, I have both one working line Gsd and Rottweiler and sometimes both are fighting to be dominant but always Gsd is winning fight… Gsd is faster and clever and his strength is like 2 rotts,.. I love both Gsd and Rott .. but ..Gsd attitude like a boss and Rotts are very aggressive kids…
Answer by Roselle RunnersRots fight dirty they go straight for the jugular and never let go.
Answer by Arvind1 Working line DDR or chezh line is enough to kill a rottweiler. Show line GSD bigger but no drive. But DDR and chezh line have high prey drive and stamina as a pitbull. Rottweiler are pitted against dogs and human during protection. GSD working line guard against wolves.I have posted a Working GSD ripping a rottweiler.
Answer by JoeGerman shepherds have a long skinny beak so they tug and pull more, which is good for attacking burglars/ human and pull tackle down.A rot has a short wide beak which is better for tearing and ripping an animal or another dog. Rottweiler’s bite is 2 times stronger than a German Shepherd.Pit bull beats Rot and German Shepherds in the long part of the fight.
Recommended Reading: How Does A German Shepherd Look Like
A Shepherd Should Live Through A Fight
In most cases, a coyote will not fight to kill anything they deem a threat. They will make a lot of noise and puff up their bodies to appear larger to scare the danger away.
But if that method doesnt work, a coyote will resort to fighting. They will attack hard enough that the threat backs out of the fight and wont interlope on the Coyotes territory anymore. But they rarely kill anything unless its a source of food.;
If a German Shepherd ends up in a fight with a coyote, they may walk away harmed, but theres a high chance they will come back alive.;
If a German Shepherd gets into a fight with a wolf, on the other hand, it will be a bloody battle to the death. Your Shepherd likely wouldnt survive.
Can Two Pitbull Kill A Lion
But with more than one pitbull, it is likely the lion would get severely wounded, despite its huge size and weight advantage. 4-5 Pitbulls can eventually kill a Lioness. However against a healthy male Lion in wild, even 10 Pitbulls have no chances. It will be a manner of seconds for a male lion to kill a Pitbull.
Read Also: What Kind Of Dogs Are German Shepherds
Cases In Which Pitbull Can Be The Winner
In general, pitbulls have lower odds of winning this fight. But, there are still some cases where they can win. If pitbull has one or more advantages over the German Shepherd, he may win. Lets see those advantages now.
When a pitbull is trained for fights
Pitbulls are fighting dogs and you can find a lot of them that are properly trained. However these days most of them are not. Anyway, if a pitbull is trained for fighting, but your German Shepherd is not, you can see that in 99% of cases pitbull will win that fight.;
German Shepherd is much older than pitbull
There is no need to explain this fact in detail. An older dog that is senior will almost always lose the fight, especially in this case scenario. On the other side, this can be a factor seen for both dogs in which case other factors from the lists will be applied.;
Purebred pitbull versus not purebred German Shepherd
If both dogs are purebred and have clean, strong genes, the German Shepherd will be the winner. But, if the German Shepherd has diluted genes and pitbull is purebred, you can assume who will win the fight. Sadly, these days many dogs have diluted genes.;
Who Would Win In A Fight A Pitbull Or A German Shepherd
German Shepherds are not used in dog fighting because they maimother dogs due to their fighting style. They charge their opponentand go for the back of the neck and shake it to break the animalsneck. If they do not make an immediate kill they release andretreat then charge again until they can finally kill the otherdog. They are very smart tactical fighters. Pitbulls, on the otherhand immediately go for the neck to try to “lock” their jaws aroundit until death. This is why Pitbulls are only fought against otherPitbulls since the fight can be decided once one dog has his jaws”locked” around the others. The fight is immediately broken up witha water hose and the dogs can fight again in the future. Pastattempts have been made to use German Shepherds against Pitbullswith bad results for both sides. PitBulls eventually get their jaws”locked” on the Shepherds but only after the Shephered have mauledand maimed them for life and left them useless for any futurefights. So the answer is neither wins. This is a general outcomebut fights are unpredictable and anything could happen.
Which Dog Is More Dangerous Pitbull Or German Shepherd
This conclusion is supported by the fact that Pit bulls and Rottweilers are responsible for the highest number of fatal attacks. German Shepherds are more dangerous than the average breed, but they are not at the top of the list.4 Sept 2019
Can A Dogo Argentino Beat A Pitbull
The Dogo Argentino and the American Pitbull Terrier are similar in looks, so much so that the Dogo Argentino is often mistaken for an APBT, and a white APBT is often mistaken for a Dogo Argentino.Breed Comparison Chart.Dogo ArgentinoPitbull TerrierLifespan9-15 years12-16 yearsPrice$2,000+$800+6 more rowsSep 18, 2020
Don’t Miss: Why Do German Shepherds Whine So Much
What Would Be The Outcome In A Coyote/german Shepherd Altercation By Charles Wood
Folks have worried about what might happen if their dog and a coyote were to confront each other: what would the outcome of a fight be? The question, Who would win in a fight between a German Shepherd and a coyote?, was posed on a forum on Quora, and answered by Charles Wood, who has given me permission to republish it here. His answer to the question:
There wouldnt be a fight, generally speaking. Let me show you why I say so.
Heres what is a stake for the coyote when a German Shepherd Dog gets interested in a coyote.
Heres team Mom and Dad coyote. Thats Mom at the left of the frame. Big. Irritable, look at her ear, end stage otitis I believe.
Heres Dad charging my dog and me. Yeah, its a bluff and we were on the other side of a chain link fence.
Now, the following photograph, I did not take, it was taken by a friend of mine, .
Coyotes intrude on each others territory all the time. They test one another looking for fun or for the chance of a gain. At stake is their food, their mate, and their children. Ive read from studies that unlike wolves, coyotes have one coyote defend their territory. Wolves Ive read just kill intruders. Coyotes? Their strategy is to give an intruder a thrashing. Enough so that an intruder wont forget. With my coyotes, Mom was there as backup and Dad did the work.
Who Would Win In A Fight A Rottweiler Or A German Shepherd
In a long distance run or agility work the German shepherd wins because of its stamina and power. Because its built is more Athletic. In a Pulling contest the Rottweiler wins because of its weight and muscles. Because the Rottweiler is slightly larger and have broader head it is stronger and have more powerful bite.
You May Like: When To Start Training Your German Shepherd
Would A German Shepherd Kill A Pitbull
The pit bull is much more likely to attack your GSD than to attack you. In either case, the GSD is not likely to be able to defend itself against a pit bull. Theyre not bred for that type of scenario. GSDs can be trained to attack, and for that matter, can be trained to kill, and thats not insignificant.
Are German Shepherd Pitbull Mix Good Dogs
They tend to shed quite a bit. When well-trained and having had plenty of exposure to kids, a German Shepherd Pit Bull is a great companion for a large family with kids. German Shepherd Pit Bulls can get along well other dogs, especially if raised with them. Socialization early on is a must for this mixed breed.
Also Check: How To Train A German Shepherd To Protect
Other Potential Temperament Issues
Both breeds can be aloof with strangers, so they require careful socialization from a young age to ensure they grow up to be polite and friendly dogs.
The German Shepherd and the Pitbull may also take part in destructive behaviors when they are bored.
They can also tend to be very exuberant when young.
Its important to keep them properly exercised and mentally stimulated every day. Check out this article on good toys for dogs with strong jaws that like to chew.
The Pitbull has a strong mind of its own and will require a knowledgeable owner to keep them under control.
Since Pitbulls were used for dog fights, they are more likely than German Shepherds to display aggression toward other dogs.
German Shepherds & Pitbulls: Character Traits
Pitbulls are particularly lovable dogs. In spite of their original purpose for being bred, they are actually people-pleasers.
They enjoy playing and having fun. They are high-energy dogs that require daily exercise. They can often forget their size and feel as if they are lap dogs, so do not be surprised if one likes to jump into your arms and lick all over your face.
They are typically very responsive to training. It is advised that training begins fairly soon after maturation. They have great mental and physical characteristics. They are also statistically known for achieving excellent temperament scores.
Read Also: How Much Food Does A German Shepherd Need
Are German Shepherds Nice Or Mean
The German Shepherd breed is known for their aggressive behaviors and tendencies. In fact, they are often touted for this behavior and it is utilized to make good, strong guard dogs. German Shepherds are considered good guard dogs but if they are not trained guard dogs, then you need to curb any aggressive tendencies.
+ Rottweiler Vs Wolf Who Would Win
I am sick of people telling me their dog is invinceable and things like that. I just want a little information to back up a theories. Thank you to all. I know I am sick of hearing people talk about their pit bull beating other dogs up too.
It’s really annoying. I don’t know though. But good luck my friend. Dogs have been bread by man for many different purposes. Herding, guarding, man stopping, fighting ect. A dogs size and strength does not make it a good fighting dog. Take the Tosa Inu for instance it is a fighting dog that gets up to or more pounds but consistently looses in the ring to the pit bull. If you are talking about pure fighting between dogs the pit bull has proven its self superior to any other breed in this department.
That does not mean it is a stronger dog, better dog, or better guard dog. Any mastiff breed is stronger bigger and makes a better home protector. Again any dog is great it just depends what you want.
A lbs mastiff will not run a marathon or clear a 8 foot fence. So the question is what purpose will your dog serve. Choose a breed accordingly. Rottweilers are not fighting dogs they have never been bread for that purpose they are in fact a herding dog that has shown aptitude for other roles such as rescue work, assistance work and to a degree some guard work. Whilst their power should never be underestimated they are are not going to win against a dog bred for that purpose.
Also Check: What Is A German Shepherd A Mix Of
Which Breed Is Healthier
So German Shepherd vs Pitbull, which is healthiest? As you can see, both are at risk for severe health conditions.
Its important to note that the German Shepherd is at a much higher risk of joint problems than the Pitbull.
They also have a much shorter lifespan with an average life expectancy of 710 years, much lower than the Pitbulls average lifespan of 1214 years.
A study that looked into the mortality of various breeds in a dataset containing over 350,000 dogs.
It was found that the German Shepherd had a significantly higher percentage of mortality when compared with other purebred breeds.
This could be due to bad breeding practices, leading to a much higher rate of serious health problems.
For this reason, we would say that the Pitbull is the healthier breed.
However, they are not without their own problems.
Regardless, many of the conditions outlined above have a genetic basis.
Therefore, it is very important that you purchase any puppies of either breed from trustworthy breeders.